| Most matches won |
|
| (25 or more) |
|
| Steve Maddalena |
91 |
| Vic Cuiss |
80 |
| Bob Zimmerman |
76 |
| Pete Walz |
75 |
| George Hoaglin |
61 |
| Mike Raymond |
57 |
| Jim Pickford |
48 |
| Mike Brockie |
48 |
| Phil Marston |
47 |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
47 |
| Bob Corley |
46 |
| Gene Hinkley |
44 |
| O.B. Smith |
42 |
| Greg Zeller |
38 |
| Bill White |
36 |
| Johnny Addison |
35 |
| Collier Bloomfield |
35 |
| Jerry Lefere |
34 |
| Joe Fiero |
34 |
| Shane Clark |
33 |
| Mel Wolf |
32 |
| Andy Andrews |
31 |
| Todd Marston |
31 |
| Bob Glick |
27 |
| Brien C. Charter |
27 |
| |
|
| Most matches played |
|
| (45 or more) |
|
| Steve Maddalena |
121 |
| Pete Walz |
114 |
| Vic Cuiss |
112 |
| Bob Zimmerman |
102 |
| George Hoaglin |
96 |
| Mike Raymond |
93 |
| Gene Hinkley |
77 |
| Jim Pickford |
69 |
| O.B. Smith |
68 |
| Mike Brockie |
67 |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
65 |
| Jerry Lefere |
64 |
| Phil Marston |
63 |
| Shane Clark |
62 |
| Greg Zeller |
61 |
| Mel Wolf |
60 |
| Bill White |
58 |
| Joe Fiero |
57 |
| Bob Corley |
56 |
| Collier Bloomfield |
56 |
| Jim Ryan |
54 |
| Roger Kuhl |
52 |
| Todd Marston |
52 |
| Andy Andrews |
51 |
| Johnny Addison |
45 |
| |
|
| Most years in |
|
| match play field |
|
| (20 or more) |
|
| Pete Walz |
42 |
| Steve Maddalena |
38 |
| George Hoaglin |
37 |
| Mike Raymond |
37 |
| Vic Cuiss |
35 |
| Gene Hinkley |
33 |
| Bob Zimmerman |
32 |
| Jerry Lefere |
31 |
| Jim Ryan |
30 |
| Shane Clark |
30 |
| O.B. Smith |
28 |
| Roger Kuhl |
28 |
| Mel Wolf |
28 |
| Jim Pickford |
25 |
| Greg Zeller |
25 |
| John Tarpley |
25 |
| Joe Fiero |
24 |
| Nathan LaZebnik |
24 |
| Hugh Pittman |
23 |
| Bill White |
22 |
| Chuck Terry |
22 |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
22 |
| Todd Marston |
22 |
| Mike Brockie |
21 |
| John Kopplin |
21 |
| Leo Miller |
21 |
| Collier Bloomfield |
21 |
| Andy Andrews |
21 |
| Phil Marston |
20 |
| Phil Johnston |
20 |
| |
|
| Most final appearances |
|
| (4 or more) |
|
| Steve Maddalena |
12 |
| Bob Zimmerman |
9 |
| Vic Cuiss |
7 |
| George Hoaglin |
7 |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
7 |
| Mike Brockie |
7 |
| Bob Corley |
6 |
| Jim Pickford |
5 |
| Johnny Addison |
5 |
| Brien C. Charter |
5 |
| Pete Walz |
5 |
| Gene Hinkley |
4 |
| Phil Marston |
4 |
| |
|
| Most consecutive |
|
| final appearances (3) |
|
| Johnny Addison |
1936-38 |
| Bob Corley |
1939-41 |
| Brien C. Charter |
1946-48 |
| Vic Cuiss |
1948-50 |
| Ted Kuzma |
1949-51 |
| Phil Marston |
1966-68 |
| |
|
| Best winning pct. (at least 20 matches) |
|
| Brien C. Charter |
.844 (27-5) |
| Ted Kuzma |
.826 (19-4) |
| Bob Corley |
.821 (46-10) |
| Dave Hill |
.818 (18-4) |
| Johnny Addison |
.778 (35-10) |
| Rex Bigelow |
.778 (21-6) |
| Brian Coon |
.767 (23-7) |
| Mike Hill |
.762 (16-5) |
| Steve Maddalena |
.752 (91-30) |
| Phil Marston |
.746 (47-16) |
| Bob Zimmerman |
.745 (76-26) |
| Jason Swihart |
.733 (22-8) |
| Steve Miller |
.727 (16-6) |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
.723 (47-18) |
| Mike Brockie |
.716 (48-19) |
| Vic Cuiss |
.714 (80-32) |
| Fred Felde |
.714 (20-8) |
| Jack DeLair |
.700 (21-9) |
| John Kurzynowski |
.700 (14-6) |
| Jim Pickford |
.696 (48-21) |
| Riley Hestwood |
.696 (16-7) |
| |
|
| Multiple winners (8) |
|
| Steve Maddalena |
'83, '87, '88, '01, '11, '16, '19, '20 |
| Multiple winners (6) |
|
| Bob Corley |
'39, '40, '41, '60, '61, '63 |
| Bob Zimmerman |
'56, '70, '71, '73, '76, '92 |
| Multiple winners (4) |
|
| Phil Marston |
'66, '67, '68, '82 |
| Jim Pickford |
'79, '84, '85, '95 |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
'99, '03, '06, '09 |
| Multiple winners (3) |
|
| Johnny Addison |
'31, '36, '38 |
| Vic Cuiss |
'49, '52, '58 |
| Pete Walz |
'81, '97, '02 |
| Multiple winners (2) |
|
| Rex Bigelow |
'30, '32 |
| Brien C. Charter |
'47, '48 |
| Steve Cole |
'72, '77 |
| Jack DeLair |
'34, '35 |
| Dave Gilpin |
'94, '96 |
| Dave Hill |
'55, '57 |
| George Hoaglin |
'74, '80 |
| Dave Kleckner |
'86, '93 |
| Ted Kuzma |
'50, '51 |
| O.B. Smith |
'44, '46 |
| Jason Swihart |
'98, '05 |
| Mike Brockie |
'10, '13 |
| Brian Coon |
'00, '23 |
| Greg Zeller |
'07, '24 |
|
|
|
| One-time winners |
|
| Andy Andrews '69 |
|
| Logan Anuszkiewicz '18 |
|
| Walt Barczak '45 |
|
| Hall Blanchard '29 |
|
| Tom Butterfield '14 |
|
| Shane Clark '89 |
|
| Tommy Conway '12 |
|
| Chris Cronenweth '91 |
|
| Zach DeFrain '22 |
|
| Scott Denig '17 |
|
| Josh Dirlam '15 |
|
| Harold Eaton '26 |
|
| Fred Felde '33 |
|
| Joe Fiero '42 |
|
| Jim Franklin '78 |
|
| Phil Goldsmith '43 |
|
| Tom Hickey '27 |
|
| Mike Hill '62 |
|
| Hubert Holmes '28 |
|
| Ken Johnson '37 |
|
| Dick Kurzynowski '64 |
|
| Jerry Lefere '75 |
|
| Todd Marston '90 |
|
| Steve Miller '54 |
|
| Ron Potok '65 |
|
| Mike Raymond '08 |
|
| Trevor Raymond (’25) |
|
| Riley Hestwood (’26) |
|
| Cannon Risner '21 |
|
| C.A. Smith III '59 |
|
| Brian Stuard '04 |
|
| Everett Winzeler '53 |
|
| |
|
| Oldest winner (65) |
|
| Greg Zeller '24 |
|
| |
|
| Youngest winner (16) |
|
| Steve Miller '54 |
|
| Ron Potok '66 |
|
| |
|
| Longest between victories: |
|
| Brian Coon, 23 years (2000-23) |
|
| |
|
| Longest span of victories: |
|
| Steve Maddalena, 37 years (1983-2020) |
|
| |
|
| Most extra holes |
|
| 14, Dave Gilpin d. Jim Pickford, 32nd, 1988 |
|
| |
|
| Longest final match |
|
| 41 holes, '89 |
|
