| Multiple winners |
| 6 |
Johnny Addison ('31, '32, '36, '37, '38, '39) |
| 6 |
Bob Zimmerman ('56, '73, '76, '77, '81, '82) |
| 5 |
Bill White ('51, '52, '53, '67, '68) |
| 5 |
Shane Clark ('89, '97, '99, '07, '08) |
| 4 |
Dave Gilpin ('88, '90, '93, '95) |
| 4 |
O.B. Smith ('40, '41, '48, '50) |
| 3 |
Merle Blackmun ('58, '59, '70) |
| 3 |
Brien C. Charter ('43, '46, '47) |
| 3 |
Pete Walz ('71, '75, '80) |
| 3 |
Mark Kurzynowski ('01, '02, '06) |
| 2 |
Rex Bigelow ('33, '42) |
| 2 |
Dave Hill ('54, '55) |
| 2 |
John Kurzynowski ('60, '64) |
| 2 |
Jerry Lefere ('72, '74) |
| 2 |
Phil Marston ('65, '66) |
| 2 |
Jim Munro ('34, '35) |
| 2 |
Ken Potok ('61, '62) |
| 2 |
Tom Tarasiewicz ('84, '85) |
| 2 |
Eric Terrian ('91, '92) |
| 2 |
Bill Scheele ('86, '96) |
| 2 |
Todd Marston ('11, '14) |
| 2 |
Mike Brockie ('15, '16) |
| Most consecutive victories |
| 4 |
Johnny Addison (1936-39) |
| 3 |
Bill White (1951-53) |
| Most consecutive match victories |
| 20 |
Johnny Addison (1936-39) |
| Longest between victories |
| 17 years |
Bob Zimmerman (1956-73) |
| Longest span between first and last victory |
| 26 years |
Bob Zimmerman (1956-82) |
| Most appearances in finals |
| 9 |
Bob Zimmerman |
| 8 |
Bill White |
| 8 |
Shane Clark |
| 7 |
Johnny Addison |
| 7 |
O.B. Smith |
| 6 |
Mark Kurzynowski |
| 6 |
Tom Tarasiewicz |
| 6 |
Dave Gilpin |
| Youngest winner |
| 16 |
Justin Bunch, 2020 |
| 16 |
Brien C. Charter, 1943 |
| Youngest finalist |
| 14 |
Brien C. Charter, 1941 |
| Oldest winner |
| 57 |
Steve Maddalena, 2017 |
| Oldest finalist |
| 62 |
Pete Walz, 2016 |
| Biggest victory in championship match |
| O.B. Smith d. Brien C. Charter, 12-11, 1941 |
| Longest playoff in championship match |
| 8 holes, 1968 |
| Most matches won (20 or more) |
| 58 |
O.B. Smith |
| 57 |
Bob Zimmerman |
| 54 |
Merle Blackmun |
| 54 |
Bill White |
| 48 |
Shane Clark |
| 48 |
Jerry Lefere |
| 45 |
Pete Walz |
| 45 |
Bill Scheele |
| 43 |
Mark Kurzynowski |
| 43 |
Dave Gilpin |
| 43 |
Tom Tarasiewicz |
| 40 |
Todd Marston |
| 39 |
Johnny Addison |
| 28 |
Bill Chittum |
| 26 |
Greg Zeller |
| 25 |
Jim Munro |
| 25 |
Mel Gilbert |
| 24 |
Ken Smith |
| 22 |
Denny Kerwin |
| 22 |
Chuck Terry |
| 21 |
Jim Clark |
| 21 |
Brien C. Charter |
| 20 |
Reggie Pulling |
| 20 |
John Cimock |
| Most matches played (35 or more) |
| 84 |
O.B. Smith |
| 81 |
Merle Blackmun |
| 76 |
Bill White |
| 76 |
Jerry Lefere |
| 75 |
Bill Scheele |
| 74 |
Bob Zimmerman |
| 68 |
Pete Walz |
| 67 |
Tom Tarasiewicz |
| 64 |
Mark Kurzynowski |
| 62 |
Shane Clark |
| 57 |
Todd Marston |
| 55 |
Dave Gilpin |
| 46 |
Ken Smith |
| 45 |
Greg Zeller |
| 43 |
Johnny Addison |
| 43 |
Chuck Terry |
| 41 |
Denny Kerwin |
| 40 |
Bill Chittum |
| 38 |
John Cimock |
| 38 |
John Tarpley |
| 37 |
Mel Gilbert |
| 35 |
Lyn Ludlow |
| Most appearances (20 or more) |
| 32 |
Bill Scheele |
| 30 |
Jerry Lefere |
| 30 |
Merle Blackmun |
| 30 |
O.B. Smith |
| 27 |
Bill White |
| 26 |
Tom Tarasiewicz |
| 26 |
Pete Walz |
| 24 |
Mark Kurzynowski |
| 23 |
Bob Zimmerman |
| 23 |
Todd Marston |
| 22 |
John Tarpley |
| 22 |
Ken Smith |
| 21 |
Chuck Terry |
| 20 |
Denny Kerwin |
| Player |
Record |
Winning Percentage |
| Johnny Addison |
39-4 |
.907 |
| Brien C. Charter |
21-4 |
.840 |
| Mike Lyons |
17-4 |
.810 |
| Jim Munro |
25-6 |
.806 |
| Dave Gilpin |
43-12 |
.782 |
| Shane Clark |
48-14 |
.774 |
| Bob Zimmerman |
57-17 |
.770 |
| Phil Marston |
18-6 |
.750 |
| Mike Brockie |
17-6 |
.739 |
| Eric Terrian |
18-7 |
.720 |
| Steve Maddalena |
15-6 |
.714 |
| Bill White |
54-22 |
.711 |
| Bill Chittum |
28-12 |
.700 |
| Marvin Boht |
18-8 |
.692 |
| O.B. Smith |
58-26 |
.690 |
| Jim Clark |
21-10 |
.677 |
| Mel Gilbert |
25-12 |
.676 |
| Mark Kurzynowski |
43-21 |
.672 |
| Merle Blackmun |
54-27 |
.667 |
| Nick Huff |
18-9 |
.667 |
| Pete Walz |
45-23 |
.662 |
| Todd Marston |
40-21 |
.656 |
| Bo Cochrane |
19-10 |
.655 |
| Tom Tarasiewicz |
43-24 |
.642 |
| Larry Leach |
16-9 |
.640 |
