| 1932 | John Thorpe d. Jack DeLair, 4-2 |  | 
| 1933 | Jack DeLair d. Fred Felde, 3-2 |  | 
| 1934 | Jack DeLair d. Carl Rutan, 6-4 |  | 
| 1935 | Art Frederick d. Harry White, 4-3 |  | 
| 1936 | Jack DeLair d. Ed Rogers, 2-1 |  | 
| 1937 | Ellsworth Earl d. Joe Fiero, 1 up, 19th |  | 
| 1938 | Ellsworth Earl d. Jack DeLair, 4-3 |  | 
| 1939 | Marvin Boht d. Darrell Cooper, 2-1 |  | 
| 1940 | No event |  | 
| 1941 | Marvin Boht | 77-73--150 | 
| 1942 | No event |  | 
| 1943 | O.B. Smith d. O.C. McPherson, 6-5 |  | 
| 1944 | Rex Bigelow d. Marvin Boht, 7-5 |  | 
| 1945 | Vic Cuiss d. O.B. Smith, 5-4 |  | 
| 1946 | Reggie Pulling d. Phil Goldsmith, 4-3 |  | 
| 1947 | Brien C. Charter d. Reggie Pulling, 1 up |  | 
| 1948 | Brien C. Charter d. O.B. Smith, 5-4 |  | 
| 1949 | Dave Heinle d. Chet Bombalicki, 1 up |  | 
| 1950 | Ted Kuzma d. Al Nichols, 12-11 |  | 
| 1951 | Vic Cuiss d. Cliff Gilbert, 7-6 |  | 
| 1952 | Vic Cuiss d. Bill White, 10-8 |  | 
| 1953 | Andy Andrews d. Tom Lockwood, 7-6 |  | 
| 1954 | Tom Lockwood d. Bob Zimmerman, 5-4 |  | 
| 1955 | Dave Hill d. Tom Lockwood, 5-4 |  | 
| 1956 | Mike Hill d. Bill White, 4-3 |  | 
| 1957 | Bill White d. Mike Hill, 10-9 |  | 
| 1958 | Bob Zimmerman d. C.A. Smith III, 2-1 |  | 
| 1959 | Vic Cuiss d. John Fielding, 12-11 |  | 
| 1960 | C.A. Smith III d. Bob Zimmerman, 4-3 |  | 
| 1961 | Mike Hill d. C.A. Smith III, 3-2 |  | 
| 1962 | Mike Hill d. Bill White, 6-5 |  | 
| 1963 | Phil Marston d. Bill White, 11-9 |  | 
| 1964 | No champion (double forfeit in final) |  | 
| 1965 | Jerry Lefere d. Ron Potok, 9-8 |  | 
| 1966 | Phil Marston | 73-73-72-75--293 | 
| 1967 | Bob Zimmerman | 75-71-75-74--295 | 
| 1968 | Jerry Lefere | 72-73-75-74--294 | 
| 1969 | Denny Vass | 75-69-75-69--288 | 
| 1970 | Jerry Lefere | 75-71-72-73--291 | 
| 1971 | Andy Andrews | 75-70-74--219 | 
| 1972 | Bob Zimmerman | 75-70-70--215 | 
| 1973 | Bill Scheele | 72-71-73--216 | 
| 1974 | Jerry Lefere | 71-75-70--216 | 
| 1975 | Andy Andrews | 73-72-79--224 | 
| 1976 | Mel Wolf* | 73-72--145 | 
| 1977 | Bob Zimmerman | 71-72--143 | 
| 1978 | David Bell | 68-78--146 | 
| 1979 | Pete Walz* | 74-73--147 | 
| 1980 | Bob Zimmerman | 71-70--141 | 
| 1981 | Pete Walz* | 77-70--147 | 
| 1982 | Bob Zimmerman | 74-68--142 | 
| 1983 | Pete Walz | 71-70--141 | 
| 1984 | Steve Maddalena | 71-71--142 | 
| 1985 | Phil Marston* | 73-71--144 | 
| 1986 | Steve Maddalena | 71-72--143 | 
| 1987 | Pete Walz* | 71-71--142 | 
| 1988 | Steve Maddalena | 74-70--144 | 
| 1989 | Phil Marston | 71-72--143 | 
| 1990 | Steve Maddalena | 69-72--141 | 
| 1991 | Steve Maddalena | 71-71--142 | 
| 1992 | Steve Maddalena* | 72-73--145 | 
| 1993 | Tom Tarasiewicz | 73-72--145 | 
| 1994 | Mike Hestwood | 74-68--142 | 
| 1995 | Pete Walz | 69-68--137 | 
| 1996 | Jeremy Rothenberger | 75-69--144 | 
| 1997 | John Tarpley* | 69-74--143 | 
| 1998 | Mark Kurzynowski | 69-71--140 | 
| 1999 | Mark Kurzynowski* | 72-70--142 | 
| 2000 | Greg Zeller* | 72-72--144 | 
| 2001 | Adam Walicki | 69-74--143 | 
| 2002 | Adam Walicki | 64-75--139 | 
| 2003 | Mark Kurzynowski | 68-72--140 | 
| 2004 | Mark Kurzynowski | 68-70--138 | 
| 2005 | Mark Kurzynowski | 71-70--141 | 
| 2006 | Jamie Clark* | 71-72--143 | 
| 2007 | Greg Zeller | 71-74--145 | 
| 2008 | Mike Brockie | 66-71--137 | 
| 2009 | Tom Butterfield* | 70-73--143 | 
| 2010 | Brett Crosthwaite | 70-71--141 | 
| 2011 | Mike Brockie | 69-73--142 | 
| 2012 | Mike Brockie | 70-70--140 | 
| 2013 | Alex LaSerra | 75-68--143 | 
| 2014 | Tom Butterfield | 68-71--139 | 
| 2015 | Mike Brockie | 67-72--139 | 
| 2016 | Cody Lysher | 67-70--137 | 
| 2017 | Josh Dirlam* | 68-72--140 | 
| 2018 | Greg Zeller | 71-69--140 | 
| 2019 | Josh Dirlam | 70-71--141 | 
| 2020 | Grant Haefner | 67-69--136 | 
| 2021 | Steve Maddalena* | 70-68--138 | 
| 2022 | Steve Maddalena | 69-68--137 | 
| 2023 | Trevor Raymond* | 69-72--141 | 
| 2024 | Jamie Clark | 69-68--137 | 
| 2025 | Bret Valkuchak | 67-70—137 | 
|  | * won playoff |  |