| Player of the Year winners: |
|
| Mike Brockie (6) |
2010, '11, '12, '13, '15, '16 |
| Mark Kurzynowski (6) |
1998, '99, '00, '02, '03, '04 |
| Steve Maddalena (5) |
2001, '08, '09, '19, '21 |
| Greg Zeller (2) |
2007, ’24 |
| Brian Coon (1) |
2023 |
| Cannon Risner (1) |
2022 |
| Cody Lysher (1) |
2021 |
| Riley Hestwood (1) |
2020 |
| Logan Anuszkiewicz (1) |
2018 |
| Josh Dirlam (1) |
2017 |
| Tom Butterfield (1) |
2014 |
| Greg Zeller (1) |
2007 |
| Shane Clark (1) |
2006 |
| Brian Stuard (1) |
2005 |
| Pete Walz (1) |
1997 |
| |
|
| Top 30 all-time Honor Roll points |
|
| Steve Maddalena | 17,727 |
| Mike Brockie | 15,141 |
| Mark Kurzynowski | 13,687 |
| Greg Zeller | 13,262 |
| Mike Raymond | 12,802 |
| Pete Walz | 10,737 |
| Shane Clark | 9,963 |
| Todd Marston | 7,408 |
| Tom Butterfield | 7,159 |
| Cody Lysher | 5,778 |
| Brian Coon | 5,530 |
| John Tarpley | 5,402 |
| Roger Kuhl | 5,199 |
| Jason Swihart | 4,648 |
| Brett Crosthwaite | 4,466 |
| Jamie Clark | 4,406 |
| Adam Walicki | 3,910 |
| Brian Stuard | 3,876 |
| Zach DeFrain | 3,389 |
| Matt Farhat | 3,193 |
| Scott Denig | 3,173 |
| Chris Chaney | 3,152 |
| Chad Risner | 3,073 |
| Riley Hestwood | 3,054 |
| Nick Huff | 3,040 |
| Josh Dirlam | 2,984 |
| Mike Boldt | 2,952 |
| Dave Mickle | 2,857 |
| Jay Foust | 2,825 |
| Bret Valkuchak | 2,600 |
