1945  
Fred Felde 77
Walter Barczak 80
Authie Meeks 80
Upty Wilkinson 83
Vic Cuiss 84
   
1946   
Brien C. Charter 74
Kelsey Cleveland 78
O.B. Smith 79
Reggie Pulling 79
Jerry Franklin 85
   
1947  
Not played  
   
1948  
Not played  
   
1949   
Vic Cuiss 70
Jerry Franklin 72
Dave Heinle 75
Reggie Pulling 75
John Smith 79
   
1950  
Ted Kuzma 71
Al Nichols 74
Dayton Pickford 76
O.B. Smith 79
Bob Glick 79
   
1951 
Ted Kuzma 74
Vic Cuiss 76
Bill White 77
Everett Winzeler   79
Upty Wilkinson 84
   
1952  
Vic Cuiss 71
Bill White 75
Vern Cunliffe 81
George Davies 85
   
1953  
Andy Andrews 75
Bill White 78
Everett Winzeler 78
Vic Cuiss 82
Phil Johnston 82
Phil Goldsmith 84
 
1954  
Dave Hill 70
Vic Cuiss 76
Steve Miller 79
Lynn MacCready 80
Tom Lockwood 81
 
1955  
Vic Cuiss* 73
Dave Hill 73
George Davies 77
C.A. Smith III 78
   
1956  
Bob Zimmerman 72
Mike Hill 74
Vic Cuiss 77
   
1957  
Dave Hill* 71
Bob Zimmerman 71
Bill White 72
Steve Miller 81
   
1958  
Bob Corley 73
Vic Cuiss 77
Bob Zimmerman 77
Steve Miller 78
Merle Blackmun 79
   
1959  
C.A. Smith III 70
Vic Cuiss 75
Bob Corley 76
Bill Pautke 76
Merle Blackmun 76
Jim Ryan 77
   
*won playoff